Analysis
Pedro Osuna asks three times why a company tied to the mayor stopped filing a required state report. Arizona doesn't require it.
He asks it three times in one video. The state agency that would collect the report says LLCs don't file one. His bigger claim, about the mayor's own disclosures, is a separate question, and it's still open.
Founder & Publisher

- Published
Full article
Watch: Osuna's Nov. 6 video on Facebook
On the afternoon of Nov. 6, Pedro Osuna posted a four-and-a-half-minute video about Mayor Douglas Nicholls and his engineering firm.
It opens with a question:
"If a city official never told the public about certain businesses he owns, starting from day one and every year after that, does that make him hard to trust? Unethical?"
At 1:30 he gets specific:
"Why has Malachite LLC not filed its required annual report with the Arizona Corporation Commission since 2023?"
He comes back to it at 2:50. And again at 4:24, near the end, where he calls them "the missing annual reports."
Three times. It's the most concrete thing in the video.
It's also wrong.
Something you should know before you read this: Osuna has written about me and this site. I'm part of this story. That's explained on the series page.
In his words
- [0:00] "If a city official never told the public about certain businesses he owns, starting from day one and every year after that, does that make him hard to trust? Unethical?"
- [1:24] "The same disclosure papers also list Malachite LLC, with him as an investor or member at that address."
- [1:30] "Why has Malachite LLC not filed its required annual report with the Arizona Corporation Commission since 2023?"
- [1:36] "If you need copies of any money movement under Malachite LLC after 2023, I can help you get them."
- [2:46] "Full disclosure of the businesses, missing from day one and every year after."
- [3:54] "Complaints based only on public records can be received and then closed for lack of jurisdiction."
- [4:21] "The missing disclosures from day one are still in the file."
How we checked the quotes: each one was transcribed from the video's own audio, then checked against the recording in a second, separate transcription pass. Where the two passes didn't agree on a word, we left it out or marked it [unclear]. Timestamps are approximate.
The report that isn't required
The Arizona Corporation Commission keeps the state's business filings. Its own FAQ answers this exact question:
"No, LLCs are not required to file annual reports. Only corporations are required to file annual reports."
Malachite LLC is an LLC. Osuna says so himself.
There's no required annual report for it to miss. There's nothing missing after 2023 because nothing was due.
This one isn't a judgment call. It takes about 30 seconds to check.
What he does with it
Right after the first mention, at 1:36, he adds:
"If you need copies of any money movement under Malachite LLC after 2023, I can help you get them."
He doesn't say what money, or what's wrong with it. The suggestion rides on a filing that was never required.
The bigger claim
The annual report is one piece. The video's main claim is bigger: that the mayor left businesses off his financial disclosures, "missing from day one and every year after."
That claim is separate, and it deserves to be checked on its own.
Here's what the video itself says about those disclosures:
- At 1:04, he says the mayor's financial disclosure papers list ownership in his engineering business and other businesses at the same address.
- At 1:24: "The same disclosure papers also list Malachite LLC."
Then, at 2:46: "Full disclosure of the businesses, missing from day one and every year after."
So the disclosures list Core Engineering and Malachite. And the disclosures are missing businesses. He doesn't say which business is missing, from which year's form.
That's the question I'd want answered before believing it.
What the law requires
Arizona law requires every city to adopt its own financial disclosure rules for local officials, consistent with the state standard. That's A.R.S. 38-545. The City of Yuma's clerk posts a financial disclosure form for elected officials and candidates.
In the video, Osuna cites a different section, 38-542, for what local officials must report. Which rules apply to a Yuma mayor, and what they require him to list, is something we're still checking.
What we haven't seen
We haven't reviewed the mayor's filed disclosure statements. They're held by the City Clerk.
Until someone puts a specific form next to a specific business and shows the gap, "missing from day one" is a claim, not a finding.
That cuts both ways. We can't say the disclosures are complete either. We'll get the statements and report what's on them.
Credit where it's due
Osuna is upfront about one limit. At 3:39, he tells viewers a complaint to the state engineering board based only on public records "can be received and then closed for lack of jurisdiction." He didn't have to say that. He did.
What Osuna says
In the posts and videos we reviewed, through Nov. 19, Osuna doesn't say what filing requirement he means or which business is missing from the mayor's disclosures.
If he responds, I'll publish what he says here.
The scorecard
Wrong
- That Malachite LLC missed a required annual report. Arizona LLCs don't file one. (Arizona Corporation Commission FAQ.)
Not verified
- That the mayor left any business off his financial disclosures. The video doesn't name one, and we haven't reviewed his filed statements.
- That anything about Malachite's finances after 2023 is improper.
Still open
- What the mayor's filed disclosure statements list, year by year.
- Which disclosure rules apply to Yuma's mayor and what they require.
Ask him yourself
These are the questions for him.
- What requirement were you referring to when you said Malachite LLC hasn't filed its required annual report?
- Which business is missing from the mayor's disclosures, and from which year's statement?
- What "money movement" under Malachite are you talking about?
If he answers, I'll print it.
You decide
He asked three times why a report wasn't filed. The state says the report isn't required.
He says the mayor's disclosures are missing businesses. His own video says they list Core Engineering and Malachite.
You can check the first one yourself in 30 seconds. The second one is still open, and we'll keep looking.
Decide how much weight the rest of the video can carry.
Earlier: Part 1: Pedro Osuna says a data center project moved to Avenue 2E. Two days later, he called it "separate." · Part 2: Pedro Osuna says Gila Electronics "lost the lawsuits." Here's how the fiber fight ended.
Where this comes from
- Osuna's Nov. 6 video. His own words.
- Arizona Corporation Commission, Business Services FAQs. Official guidance from the state agency that keeps business filings.
- A.R.S. 38-545. State law requiring cities to adopt financial disclosure standards.
- City of Yuma, campaign finance and disclosure forms. The City's financial disclosure form for elected officials and candidates.
The series: The Yuma Dossier, Checked
Related topics 1
- The Yuma Dossier, Checked
Pedro Osuna calls himself a research journalist and his videos the Yuma Dossier. He says everything is on the public record. So we put his claims next to the record, one at a time.