YUMA, ARIZONAYuma news. Local context. Evidence you can check.

Analysis

Pedro Osuna says Gila Electronics "lost the lawsuits." A judge stopped the project, and the settlement owed Gila $2 million.

A judge stopped construction on the county's fiber network. Then a settlement required $2 million in payments to Gila. Osuna's account leaves both out.

Founder & Publisher

Updated
Did Gila lose the lawsuits? A judge halted construction. The settlement required $2 million in payments to Gila.
Credit: Yuma Informed
Published

Full article

Watch: Osuna's Nov. 9 video on Facebook

At 12:31 on the afternoon of Nov. 9, Pedro Osuna posted this on Facebook:

"After Gila Electronics and its allies lost the procurement, the lawsuits, and the SB 1487 investigation, the completed fiber ended up running directly adjacent to Harold Hendrick's 10-acre parcel at 14255 S. Avenue 2E."

Six minutes later he posted a five-minute video telling the same story. He posted it again at 1:12 p.m. Same audio both times.

The video walks through the fight over Yuma County's middle-mile fiber network. Bid. Protest. Lawsuit. Attorney general. Then, at 2:22:

"Construction continued."

That's where his account of the court fight ends.

The court record doesn't end there.

Something you should know before you read this: Osuna has written about me and this site. I'm part of this story. That's explained on the series page.

In his words

The full video is linked above. These are the lines this story checks.

  • [0:15 to 0:17] "a failed middle-mile fiber bid and an SB 1487 inquiry"
  • [1:54 to 1:57] "The board awarded the contract to [ALLO] with Lines casting the only dissenting votes."
  • [1:59] "Gila and [unclear] sued."
  • [2:18 to 2:22] "The AG closed it in July 2024 as unsubstantiated. Construction continued."
  • [4:15 to 4:22] "The public record shows a clear progression, contested procurement, litigation, an SB 1487 inquiry, adjacent fiber construction ..."

How we checked the quotes: each one was transcribed from the video's own audio, then checked against the recording in a second, separate transcription pass. Where the two passes didn't agree on a word, we left it out or marked it [unclear]. Timestamps are approximate.

What he gets right

Start with what holds up.

  • ALLO got the contract. The Board of Supervisors approved the ALLO agreement 4-1 on Jan. 26, 2022.
  • Supervisor Jonathan Lines voted no. Osuna says so, and he's right.
  • The attorney general's inquiry ended without a finding against the county. State legislators asked the attorney general to look at the deal under SB 1487. The attorney general's docket shows the request was converted to a public monies complaint. The county says the attorney general later found the Gift Clause allegation unsubstantiated.
  • The network got built. ALLO kept the contract and the project went ahead. The county's March 16, 2026 packet lists about $29.75 million in budgeted project funding, including the $10 million federal Capital Projects Fund grant, program income and interest.

The fight lasted years, and Gila didn't get the contract.

What he leaves out

Here's the part that's missing from both the post and the video.

  • October 2024: A judge granted Gila a preliminary injunction. It stopped construction and payments on the network, with exceptions for operations and maintenance.
  • December 2024: The parties settled. Yuma County agreed to pay Gila $750,000. ALLO agreed to pay Gila $1.25 million. That's $2 million total.
  • After the settlement: The case was dismissed with prejudice, meaning it can't be refiled. ALLO kept the contract.

So the project didn't simply roll on after the attorney general weighed in. A judge stopped it. Then a settlement required the county and ALLO to pay Gila $2 million to end the case. The county's audited report confirms the county issued its $750,000 payment.

Is that losing?

To be fair, Gila didn't win either. There was no ruling for Gila on the merits. ALLO kept the contract. The network was finished.

It wasn't a clean loss, though. A company that "lost the lawsuits" doesn't usually walk away with a court order that halted the project and a settlement requiring $2 million in payments to it.

The record supports something in between. Osuna's account picks one end of it.

That matters for his larger story. In his telling, Gila is the outsider pushed aside while a small circle of insiders takes the corridor. The settlement doesn't prove or disprove that story. But a reader deciding whether to believe it should know the settlement money was owed to Gila.

Twice, not once

This isn't a single slip.

The written post says "lost the lawsuits." The video, posted the same afternoon, tells the court fight without the injunction or the settlement. Two different formats. The same gap.

What we haven't checked yet

The video makes other claims we haven't finished checking. We're not passing them along as fact.

  • A 2022 county approval for the mayor's firm. At 3:29, Osuna says Core Engineering "received county approval in March 2022 to inspect the backbone." If that's in the county's records, it's worth its own story. We're checking.
  • The timing of the attorney general request. Osuna says the request came 12 days after Gila hired lobbyists. We haven't checked lobbyist registrations.

We'll report what we find, whichever way it goes.

What Osuna says

In the posts and videos we reviewed, through Nov. 19, Osuna doesn't mention the injunction or the settlement.

If he responds, I'll publish what he says here.

The scorecard

Verified

  • ALLO won the contract, 4-1, with Lines voting no. (County minutes.)
  • The attorney general's inquiry was converted to a public monies complaint, and the county says the attorney general found the Gift Clause allegation unsubstantiated. (Attorney general docket; county statement.)
  • In October 2024 a judge granted Gila a preliminary injunction halting construction and payments. (County statement.)
  • In December 2024 the settlement required the county to pay Gila $750,000 and ALLO to pay $1.25 million. The county's payment was issued. The case was dismissed with prejudice and ALLO kept the contract. (Audited county financial report.)

Not separately documented

  • ALLO's $1.25 million payment. The settlement required it. We haven't seen a record of the payment itself.

Left out of Osuna's account

  • The injunction.
  • The settlement requiring $2 million in payments to Gila.

Not verified

  • Osuna's claims about the March 2022 county approval and the lobbyist timing.

Ask him yourself

These are the questions for him.

  1. Why did your post and your video leave out the injunction and the $2 million settlement?
  2. Do you still say Gila "lost the lawsuits"?
  3. Will you update the post?

If he answers, I'll print it.

You decide

He says Gila lost the lawsuits.

The record says a judge stopped the project, and the settlement required $2 million in payments to Gila.

Read the county's statement. Read the audited report. Decide what "lost" means.

Next: In another video, Osuna asks three times why a company tied to the mayor stopped filing a required state report. Arizona doesn't require that report. Read Part 3

Earlier: Part 1: Pedro Osuna says a data center project moved to Avenue 2E. Two days later, he called it "separate."

Where this comes from

The series: The Yuma Dossier, Checked

Share this article

Related topics 1

  • The Yuma Dossier, Checked

    Pedro Osuna calls himself a research journalist and his videos the Yuma Dossier. He says everything is on the public record. So we put his claims next to the record, one at a time.