Explainer
Arizona wants new dust rules for Yuma. County supervisors want to know who will pay.
Arizona has proposed new rules to cut blowing dust around Yuma, covering construction sites, vacant land, unpaved roads and farms. Two county supervisors told the state local taxpayers shouldn’t carry the cost of dust the county doesn’t control.
Founder & Publisher

- Published
Full article
<p>If you’ve lived here through a windy spring afternoon, you already know Yuma has a dust problem. The federal government has had it in writing since 1991.</p><p>On Nov. 6, 1991, part of Yuma County was classified as a “nonattainment area” for PM10. That’s coarse particle pollution, 10 microns and smaller, the kind that comes off dirt roads, bare ground, construction sites and open desert when the wind picks up. Nonattainment means the area has broken the federal health standard, and Arizona owes the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency a plan to fix it. <a href="https://azdeq.gov/node/4374">ADEQ’s history of the Yuma area</a> lists that designation date.</p><p>The story since then hasn’t been a straight line. At one point EPA found Yuma’s air had cleaned up enough to meet the standard. In 2022, EPA withdrew that finding, saying more recent monitoring showed the area had violated the standard again. In the same action, EPA called Arizona’s plan for Yuma “substantially inadequate” and told the state to write a new one. That order took effect June 16, 2022, according to <a href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2022-05-17/html/2022-10060.htm">EPA’s Federal Register action</a>.</p><p>The new rules are now on the table.</p><h2>What the state proposed</h2><p>The Arizona Department of Environmental Quality published its proposed rules in the Oct. 9, 2026, Arizona Administrative Register. Public comment closed Nov. 9. The <a href="https://apps.azsos.gov/public_services/register/2026/41/contents.pdf">official Register text</a> sets thresholds for the land and operations covered:</p><ul><li><strong>Construction.</strong> Sites that disturb at least one acre would have to follow dust-control requirements.</li><li><strong>Vacant and open areas.</strong> Lots with at least 1,000 square feet of disturbed ground would be covered when the overall area is larger than a tenth of an acre in urban areas, or half an acre in rural areas.</li><li><strong>Unpaved roads.</strong> Dirt roads averaging at least 150 vehicle trips a day would fall under dust-control provisions.</li><li><strong>Agriculture,</strong> through dust-control practices on farms.</li></ul><p>In other words, this isn’t aimed at somebody’s backyard. It’s aimed at the bigger, busier patches of bare dirt that the wind keeps picking up.</p><p>ADEQ has been clear about the alternative. If Arizona doesn’t produce a plan EPA accepts, the federal government can impose its own, called a Federal Implementation Plan.</p><h2>What the county told the state</h2><p>Supervisors Jonathan Lines and Darren Simmons testified before ADEQ on the plan, according to the <a href="https://www.yumasun.com/news/supervisors-lines-simmons-testify-on-pollution-plan-for-county/article_97a86920-7449-4103-81ce-d0a7306f20d5.html">Yuma Sun’s report</a>. Lines did most of the talking. Simmons said his comments mirrored Lines’s and that the county can’t accept added requirements that cost taxpayers.</p><p>Lines’s argument, boiled down: the county supports clean air, but local taxpayers shouldn’t carry a disproportionate share of the cost for dust the county can’t control.</p><p>Part of his case was about who owns the land. By the figures in his testimony, about 89 percent of Yuma County’s roughly 3.5 million acres is held by federal, state or local government, and about 80.6 percent is federal. Private farmland is about 5.3 percent. Arizona State Trust land is about 7.6 percent. Yuma County also borders California and Mexico, and dust doesn’t stop at a line on a map.</p><p>That’s an argument about jurisdiction and cost. It isn’t a measurement of where Yuma’s dust comes from. How much blows off federal land, how much comes across the border, and how much comes from natural events are exactly the questions Lines asked ADEQ to answer.</p><p>For every new requirement, he asked three things:</p><ul><li>What will it cost?</li><li>How much PM10 will it actually remove?</li><li>Is there a cheaper way to get the same result or better?</li></ul><p>He also asked for an itemized estimate of what the plan would cost the county in equipment and ongoing work like road sweeping, dust suppression and staff time, and for the science behind the rules: emissions inventories, monitoring data, weather assumptions and modeling.</p><h2>What happens next</h2><p>ADEQ has to respond to the comments it received, finalize the rules, and send the revised plan to EPA, which approves or rejects it.</p><p>We don’t yet know how ADEQ will answer the county, who else commented, or how long the state has before federal sanctions or a federal plan come into play. We’ll update this story as those answers come in.</p>