Explainer
State school grades are out. Two District One schools got D's, and Yuma Union High lost its two A's.
KAWC's list of the 2025-26 grades shows the only Yuma County D's at Castle Dome Middle and O.C. Johnson Elementary, and every YUHSD high school at a B. Statewide, D's and F's went up, and the state is rewriting the system.
Founder & Publisher

- Published
Full article
Every fall, Arizona hands its public schools a letter grade. Parents check them. Realtors quote them. Districts hang banners for the good ones.
This year's are out, and today, Nov. 17, is the last day schools can appeal.
One thing up front about where these grades come from. The state publishes the full list in a spreadsheet on the State Board of Education's website. I tried to get it this morning and couldn't. The site put up a "verify you're human" screen I couldn't get past, and the state's report card site only goes through last school year so far. So every 2025-26 grade below is as KAWC reported it on Nov. 16. KAWC's story credits the grades to the Arizona Department of Education.
The two D's
KAWC reported three D's across Yuma and La Paz counties, and no F's. Two of the D's are in Yuma County, both in Yuma Elementary School District One: Castle Dome Middle School and O.C. Johnson Elementary.
The third, Bouse Elementary, is in La Paz County.
One District One school went the other way. Gila Vista Junior High was the only local D last year, KAWC reported. This year it's a C.
YUHSD: no more A's
All seven Yuma Union High School District high schools got a B this year, according to KAWC's list: Cibola, Gila Ridge, Kofa, San Luis, Somerton, Vista and Yuma.
Last year Gila Ridge and San Luis both had A's, KYMA reported at the time. So the district went from two A's to none.
A B is still "highly performing" in the state's own language. But it's a change, and it lines up with what happened across Arizona.
The A's
KAWC listed 15 A schools across the two counties. In Yuma County that includes Centennial Middle, Gary A. Knox Elementary, Gowan Science Academy and H.L. Suverkrup Elementary in Crane; Desert Sonora, Orange Grove and Tierra Del Sol elementaries in Somerton; Desert View Elementary and Southwest Junior High (now Southwest Early College Academy) in Gadsden; James B. Rolle and Palmcroft elementaries in District One; Mohawk Valley School; and two charters, Desert View Academy and Harvest Preparatory Academy.
KAWC's full list, including the B's and C's, is linked below. It isn't every school in the county. If your school isn't on it, that doesn't tell you its grade, and the state's report card site is the place to check once this year's numbers are posted there.
Across Arizona, the bottom got bigger
Statewide, the share of schools getting a D or F went up. KTAR reported the share of K-8 schools rated D or F rose from 4 percent last year to 6.7 percent. For high schools it jumped from 1.8 percent to 8 percent.
About those grades
There's a reason to read all of this with one eyebrow raised.
In June, the Arizona Auditor General said the system doesn't clearly communicate how schools are doing. The audit found it gave A's or B's to more than 77 percent of traditional K-8 and high schools, and that a school could land a B even when few of its students were proficient. It pointed to old cut points and bonus points as part of the problem.
The State Board is now rewriting the system. In August it voted unanimously to drop bonus points, according to KAWC. KAWC reported that Arizona was the only state with a bonus-points category. The board has said every school will still be able to earn an A, but how many A's and B's get handed out may change. The first grades under the new rules come out in October 2027, for the 2026-27 school year.
So this year's grades come from a system the state's own auditor said may inflate grades, and next year's will come from a different one. Comparing across years is going to get harder before it gets easier.
What I couldn't find
The state's own file. It would let me confirm each grade directly, list every school in the county instead of the ones KAWC named, and give a Yuma County-only breakdown. KAWC's percentages (23 percent A, 53 percent B, 20 percent C, 5 percent D) cover Yuma and La Paz counties together. When the file opens up, I'll check this story against it and update.
District reaction. I couldn't find a posted statement on this year's grades from District One, YUHSD, Crane, Gadsden or Somerton.
Appeals. I don't know whether any Yuma County school appealed. KAWC noted grades can still change for schools that do.
Related
Grades are one measure. Money is another. Yuma's two biggest districts spend in the 40s on the classroom, and voters here just told them to get to 60 percent. Statewide, Arizona went the other way.
Where this comes from
- KAWC, "Most Yuma, La Paz schools earn A or B grades on state report cards," Sisko J. Stargazer, Nov. 16, 2026. Reporting. Source for every 2025-26 grade named, Gila Vista's prior D, the combined percentages and the Nov. 17 appeal deadline. KAWC
- KYMA, "Yuma High School District receives letter grades for 2024-25 school year," Oct. 30, 2025. Reporting. Gila Ridge and San Luis A's last year. KYMA
- KTAR, Oct. 29, 2026. Reporting. Statewide D and F shares. KTAR
- Arizona Auditor General, Report 26-101, June 2026. Official performance audit of the A-F system. Report
- KAWC, Aug. 25, 2026. Reporting. State Board's bonus-points vote and timeline. KAWC
- Arizona State Board of Education, A-F letter grades page. Official. Not accessible for independent review on Nov. 17. azsbe.az.gov
Sources 6
- Secondary source / research lead · News report2026 Arizona letter grades are out: Percentage of schools getting D's or F's rises
KTAR report dated October 29, 2026. Reports statewide K-8 D/F shares of 4% and 6.7%, and high-school shares of 1.8% and 8%, for the prior and current years. Independently reviewed before publication.
- Primary source · Government recordArizona Auditor General Report 26-101: school accountability system, June 2026
Supporting source for the November 17, 2026 article. Scope and limitations are explained in the article and linked original.
- Primary source · Government recordazsbe.az.gov: a f school letter grades
Official Arizona State Board school-grades hub. The 2025-26 spreadsheet could not be independently accessed; current individual grades in the article are attributed to KAWC.
- Secondary source / research lead · News reportMost Yuma, La Paz schools earn A or B grades on state report cards
Supporting source for the November 17, 2026 article. Scope and limitations are explained in the article and linked original.
- Secondary source / research lead · News reportState board takes first step in revising Arizona’s A-F school grades
Supporting source for the November 17, 2026 article. Scope and limitations are explained in the article and linked original.
- Secondary source / research lead · News reportYuma High School District receives letter grades for 2024-25 school year - KYMA
Supporting source for the November 17, 2026 article. Scope and limitations are explained in the article and linked original.
Related topics 1
- Gadsden school board election and district oversight
Reporting on candidates for the Gadsden Elementary School District board, district policy, budgets, compensation and oversight.