YUMA, ARIZONAYuma news. Local context. Evidence you can check.

Update

Supervisors pick the $8.6 million option for county maintenance and IT crews. Their engineers recommended a different one.

Yuma County's Facilities crew has 44 people in under 3,000 square feet. Supervisors finally picked a fix, the cheapest of three. County Engineering had recommended another option, and the price tag isn't the one we reported in October.

Founder & Publisher

Updated
Option 1 costs an estimated $8.6 million. Supervisors chose the cheapest option. Engineers recommended a different plan.
Credit: Graphic supplied by Yuma Informed
Published

Full article

Forty-four people. Just under 3,000 square feet of office space.

That's the county's Facilities Management department, the crew that keeps every county building running, according to the minutes of the Oct. 19 board meeting. Those minutes also say this project started in 2018.

On Nov. 16, supervisors finally picked a plan. It's the cheapest of the three. It's not the one their engineers recommended.

What they picked

Option 1 builds Facilities a new building of up to 7,500 square feet. IT, with 33 employees, doesn't get a new building. It moves into 198 S. Main St., the former county administration building.

The county's estimate: $8.6 million. About $5.6 million is the Facilities building and about $3 million is the IT work at 198 S. Main, with a 30 percent contingency built in.

Options 2 and 3 would have built at the county's Avenue B site, for up to $10.1 million. That's about the size of the budget set aside for this.

What Engineering said

The last slide in the county's presentation is pretty direct: "ENGINEERING RECOMMENDATION: Proceed with Option 3 (separate buildings)."

Staff also listed the downsides of Option 1. IT doesn't get a new building. There's no secured parking for the nine county IT vehicles that carry sensitive equipment. And the restrooms at 198 S. Main need major work before the building can be occupied and meet ADA rules.

Boards don't have to follow staff. When they don't, the reasoning usually ends up in the minutes. Those aren't posted yet.

The vote

The county's official record doesn't show the vote yet. Its outcome line for this item reads "Other (See minutes)."

The Yuma Sun reported the vote was 3-2 for Option 1, plus a structural engineering assessment of the building. According to the Sun, Chairman Martin Porchas and Supervisors Darren Simmons and Jonathan Lines voted yes, and Supervisors Tony Reyes and Lynne Pancrazi voted no. The Sun reported Simmons cited about $1.5 million in savings.

That number lines up with the county's figures: $10.1 million minus $8.6 million is $1.5 million.

About that $7 million

On Oct. 30 we reported, citing the Yuma Sun, that Option 1 would cost about $7 million. The Nov. 16 packet says $8.6 million.

Here's what the records show. On Oct. 19, the board asked for detailed costs on renovating 198 S. Main. The Nov. 16 slides break out the IT work there at about $3 million, and separately list $715,000 for building systems at 198, like the fire alarm and the elevator.

What the records don't say is whether the job got bigger or the estimate just got sharper. So I'm not calling it a price increase. It's two estimates from two dates.

A real number is coming soon, sort of. The packet notes that bids on a similar building for the University of Arizona Cooperative Extension are due Dec. 2. County staff say those bids will show whether these estimates hold up.

What we don't know yet

  • The official vote. Waiting on the minutes.
  • What the structural assessment costs, and what happens if it finds problems.
  • Where the new Facilities building goes.
  • Why the board went with Option 1 over Engineering's pick, beyond the savings the Sun reported.

Where this comes from

Share this article

Sources 4