YUMA, ARIZONAYuma news. Local context. Evidence you can check.

News

San Luis picked a mayor by 10 votes. Now comes the recount.

James Allen Jr. leads Matias Rosales 2,612 to 2,602. That's close enough to force an automatic recount. The county says two more races will be recounted, but the published numbers don't fit the law, at least not yet.

Founder & Publisher

Updated
View from Friendship Park in San Luis toward a border fence and San Luis Río Colorado.
Credit: Photo: Ken Lund / Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/
Published

Full article

Ten votes.

That's the gap in the San Luis mayor's race in Yuma County's latest unofficial results, posted at 4:28 p.m. Thursday, Nov. 12. James Allen Jr. has 2,612. Matias Rosales has 2,602. Seven people wrote someone in.

It started the other way around. In the City of San Luis's first preliminary numbers, posted Nov. 4, Rosales led 1,397 to 1,253. He still led 1,540 to 1,386 in our Nov. 5 results update. Somewhere in the ballots counted after that, the lead changed hands.

View from Friendship Park in San Luis toward a border fence and San Luis Río Colorado.
Credit: Photo: Ken Lund / Flickr, CC BY-SA 2.0. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/

Friendship Park in San Luis. Photo: Ken Lund / [Flickr](https://www.flickr.com/photos/kenlund/4409899348/), [CC BY-SA 2.0](https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/2.0/)

This one gets a recount

Arizona's automatic-recount law, A.R.S. 16-661, kicks in when the gap between the top two is one-half of 1 percent or less of the votes those two received.

Ten out of 5,214 is 0.19 percent. Well under the line.

KAWC reported Thursday that County Recorder David Lara said the race will have an automatic recount and that the court will set the date. The law ties the recount to the canvass, the official tally, and Superior Court orders it.

There are two canvasses to watch:

  • Yuma County Board of Supervisors: 9 a.m. Monday, Nov. 16.
  • San Luis City Council: The city says its results become official once the council canvasses them. It hasn't posted a date.

Until the canvass and the recount are done, nobody has won this race.

Two more recounts, and a math problem

Lara also told KAWC there will be recounts in two more races. KAWC reported what he said in its own words, not as direct quotes.

  • Somerton City Council, second of two seats. Brian Lopez has 872. Juan Castillo, the vice mayor, has 848. That's 24 votes.
  • Gadsden Elementary School District board, third of three seats. Brian Alaniz de la Hoya has 1,689. Luis "Cuate1" Marquez has 1,559. That's 130 votes.

Here's the problem. Neither race meets the automatic-recount test in the county's published numbers.

In Somerton, 24 votes is 1.4 percent of the 1,720 votes Lopez and Castillo received. The half-percent line would be about 8 votes. (That compares the last candidate in line for a seat with the first one out, which is how we read the law for a two-seat race.)

Gadsden is simpler. The automatic-recount law says outright that it doesn't apply to school district governing boards.

That doesn't mean anybody got anything wrong. Both races were far tighter a week ago. Our Nov. 7 results update had Somerton at 603 to 600 and Gadsden at 1,157 to 1,149. The recount talk may date from then. There may be another rule we haven't found. Or something may have shifted between what Lara said and how it was reported. We don't know which, and we'll update this when we do.

The rest of San Luis

Two City Council seats were on the ballot. Javier Vargas leads with 2,851, followed by Octavio Ramirez with 2,598. Luisa Arreola has 2,121 and Ruben Walshe Peralta has 1,433. All unofficial until the canvass.

What's next

  • Friday, Nov. 13: KAWC reported the county expected to post final unofficial results today. If the numbers move, this story will too.
  • Monday, Nov. 16, 9 a.m.: Board of Supervisors canvass.
  • San Luis City Council canvass: date not posted.
  • The recount: ordered by Superior Court. No date yet.

Full countywide results are in our Nov. 3 election results story.](https://yumainformed.com/articles/yuma-county-election-results-november-3-2026).)

Where this comes from

Related

Share this article

Sources 6